Log In or Register

Final Fantasy ISN'T the ONLY RPG out there (My Rant)

Okay, here it is. The blog about the subject that i have so much trouble with and which annoys me more than any other subject. So, is this going to be me talking about how much Final Fantasy Sucks like a normal rant? well NO its not, and thats because Final Fantasy doesn't suck. Final Fantasy is a quite good rpg series. Not the best, but they're good. So am i here to poke fun at the fact that FF7 was rubbish and didnt deserve all the spinoffs and fame? NO, not that either. So whats the point of this blog?

Well, i'll give you a quote of conversations i had with two of my friends at college.

Conversation 1 :
"Hey, Digital Devil Saga's FINALLY come out in the UK, its a really quite good rpg"
"nah i only play Final Fantasy"

Conversation 2 :
"You like RPG's right? Dragon Quest VIII is quite good"
"Its by Square? Is it the same guys who did Final Fantasy?"
"actually no, its made by Enix"
"oh ... well, not really that interested"

you see? i know thats only two examples, but the point is still the same. Final Fantasy is popular, and its spread into EVERY rpg genre in the J-RPG list. As I mentioned before, these games arent that bad, and as a HUGE RPG fan myself, i play them and i do enjoy them, but at the moment they're swamping all the other rpgs.

In my local game shops, if a Final Fantasy game comes out, they've got it RIGHT by the door in huge amounts with special offers on drawing your eyes to them.

But what about everything else? None of the Megami Tensei games have had that. Persona 3 didnt even appear on the shelves on our shops til about three/four months after its release, and even then it was one copy in the entire store. I'll admit that the situation is worse in the UK than the US, but it still shouldnt be happening anywhere at all. Even Lost Oddysey and Blue Dragon, rpgs made by the original creator of Final Fantasy, didnt get THAT much of a promotion. there was a copy in the "new releases" shelf for a few days without much promotion.

People may counter this with saying that "there arent any other rpgs out there to play", well thats a symptom. The less people who buy these rpgs, the less they'll keep them in stock, and the less they keep them in stock, the smaller chance the true RPG fans get of playing these games.

Another counter might be "other games just arent as good as Final Fantasy", well i bring up this point. Take a lesser known RPG like ... Rogue Galaxy (it's lesser known in the UK, cant speak for the US). It didnt sell well, and you can pick it up for a fiver (not me though, got it when it came out ^^). However, if youd release that under the name Final Fantasy : Rogue Galaxy, i GUARANTEE you the amount of preorders would be higher than Goku's power level on the scouter (thats right, over 8000!!! yeah take that Dub watchers), and everyone would love it and talk about how its the best rpg ever. Not that it would matter about the game anyway, It doesnt even matter what the games like, or if any screenshots have been released, if we just got a marking up of "unnamed Final Fantasy Project", the preorders would STILL go in.

Finally, i have to point out this. These RPGs had a LOT of time put behind them, with a lot of work to bring them over to America and England. Too much work and effort for a gamer to just dismiss the game simply because its not got the name Final Fantasy on it. After all, the developers have put a LOT of time in to make this game work right (I worked as a Beta Tester, trust me I know how much work is required just to do THAT), so isnt it unfair to mark them as not worth playing just because of a name?

So ive posted what i have problems with, so what can you do about it? Well, its simple. Pick up a NEW rpg. Something that isnt Final Fantasy, and give it a fair try.

p.s. Notice, i have not tried to say that FF are worse than other games, or that they suck in any way, simply that the other games deserve a try, so please dont treat this like a FF bashing topic because its not! ive got no problem with FF itself, its the Fanatics who play nothing else that i have the problem with.

Average: 4.4 (9 votes)

Although I'm a HUGE final

Although I'm a HUGE final fantasy fan (1-6 only), I agree that there are plenty of other good RPGs out there, except that people are scared to buy them. While the FF games are known to be continuously good, others aren't as well known, meaning you're going to be more cautious with your cash. Other RPGs I enjoy are EarthBound, Golden Sun, Paper Mario and M&L Superstar Saga (not true RPGs, but fun anyways).
---------------
"What is the difference between a man and a parasite? A man builds. A parasite asks 'Where is my share?' A man creates. A parasite says, 'What will the neighbors think?' A man invents. A parasite says, 'Watch out, or you might tread on the toes of God...'" -Andrew Ryan

Good point.

I'm in the minority when it comes to RPGs. Unlike most people my favorite RPG isn't Final Fantasy VII, it's Panzer Dragoon Saga. Most RPGs I've played, FFVII included I've only played through once and in some cased I've even gotten frustrated and never reached the end. Panzer Dragoon Saga on the other hand is so good, even though it is kind of short by RPG standards, I've played it all the way through several times and unlocked all its secrets.

You hit the nail right on the head, there are other RPGs out there and many are even better than Final Fantasy.

-- --- .-. ... . / -.-. --- -.. .
I'm an old school gamer, but I'm still hip. Wait, when referring to oneself as, "Hip", does it reverse its meaning?

RPGs

Good blog man!

Yeah, that always annoys me as well. I reckon that if you only get Final Fantasy games, you're gonna miss out big time. Some good examples would Breath of Fire and Golden Sun but my all-time favourite would be Chrono Cross.

I have to agree. The main

I have to agree. The main FF's have been so consistent in their quality (i.e. all considered at least good) many people are quite scared to try other games and series.

Have you ever seen a people makes lists like "Top 10 Reasons JRPGs Suck" and then just about every example they can come up with comes from a FF. Somehow they don't seem to realize there are tons of counter examples to their issues in series other than Final Fantasy. If these people would just stop being ignorant troglodytes and play other games (or listen to people that play them, since most trolls don't ever play the games they complain about) the JRPG might not have such a bad rap these days.

Two Words

Chrono Trigger.

In my opinion, still the greatest RPG ever made. Square will have to do a lot to top what they did over a decade ago.

However, your points are valid. Square, while they do make incredibly fine RPG's under the Final Fantasy name, are not the only RPG makers out there. Enix did some great things before they were assimilated. Also there exists some great titles out there, like the Star Ocean series, Golden Sun (Incredibly deep for a handheld title), etc.

I can still see where some people are coming from though. Final Fantasy titles are exceptionally well made in most cases. Final Fantasies IV, VI, VII, and X are all testaments to that. It's also gotten to the point where each Final Fantasy is so different from the one before it gameplay and design-wise that they can essentially be their own standalone games.

An' here's two more for ya!

Working. Designs.

Y'know as in "Our games go to 11!" And manoman did they! Lunar the Silver Star remains to this day one of the best games I have ever played (RPGs are my 2nd favorite genre by the way.) Later on the Saturn Dragon Force and Shining Wisdom became favorites as well. For anyone who has ever played them, Working Designs just did not make a sucky RPG. God, I wish they were still around....

As far as for people who refuse to play anything but Final Fantasy I say let people like and play whatever they want. If they never get to know great games like Sudeki, Persona, Suikoden, Etrian Odyssey, Wild Arms, Izuna the unemployed Ninja or Mass Effect and Knights of the Old Republic then isn't that their loss?

I couldn't agree more though about the fact that these games DO deserve to be just as popular. For some reason I have never owned the right system to play the Final Fantasy series so I have had to "make due". Now I have a DS and so I can enjoy some of the earlier entries in the series and while I enjoy III, I wouldn't say that it's so good I would play it to the exclusion of all other RPG's. I wouldn't say that about any RPG series. Not even Phantasy Star which is what got me started on them and the only series that I have played every game to completion for, right up to and including PSO for the XBOX. Ah.....PSO until 4am with my live buddies....good times....good times.

Admittedly PSO on it's own would probably not make most folks favorites list (particularly with the 5 second XBOX Live voice lag) but there is just something unspeakably (at least in a timely manner) hillarious about having a dragon suddenly land behind you, blast you in the back and send you reeling only to hear five seconds later....."Look Out!!"

In fact I've had so much fun with RPGs that aren't made by Square that I guess I CAN feel something for those who refuse to play anything else: Sorry.

"We can do far more than we think so long as we're willing to think far more than we do."

well

if people didn't only play final fantasy working desighns might still be around. i still weep for more lunar games.

kind of a self defeating arguement.

Even though it an adventure

Even though it an adventure game and not strictly an RPG, Popful Mail deserves to be mentioned. It's one of the best releases by working designs and not just on the Sega CD.

-- --- .-. ... . / -.-. --- -.. .
I'm an old school gamer, but I'm still hip. Wait, when referring to oneself as, "Hip", does it reverse its meaning?

Wow!

Someone else knows Working Designs! They were a game developer in Redding. I kinda wish they were still here too, but for selfish reasons...

There are other RPGs out

There are other RPGs out there other than the Final Fantasy games but you should know that people always go for what's popular, familiar and widely known for being nothing but greatness. The Final Fantasy series is the landmark, the capital and the very heart and soul of RPGs. I hate to say it but there are a few great titles that could've never existed and the RPG would not be very different, but what about Final Fantasy? Had it not been for FF4, FF6 and ultimately, FF7 (It doesn't suck. Shut up, you don't know anything.), RPGs probably would not have made it mainstream and it would've been VASTLY overlooked today by all but the most hardcore of gamers.

Sadly, casual RPG players won't feel very comfortably playing anything else, which leaves a lot of amazing games untouched by the masses. When people hear RPG, they immediately think Final Fantasy and that's just how it is.

Well, first of all i didnt

Well, first of all i didnt say that FF7 sucks, i just used it as an example of the topics people USUALLY USE in discussions about Final Fantasy. I dont mind FF7 at all. Okay its not the best but its not perfect, and i dont appreciate being told to shut up and that I "dont know anything".

Also, what happened when these gamers first picked up Final Fantasy? back then it was a game that people hadnt played before, but they picked it up to give it a try. So, if they managed to pick up that game when it was new to them, why did they suddenly lose the ability to try something new afterwards?

Well I will be flat out honest I...

do like Final Fantasy In fact I like Final fantasy VI (screw VII and it's hype damn it)

but I also like Dragon Quest and phantasy star and Phanzer Dragon there are more RPG's out there I hate people who brag on about just FF like there all that good...trust me there are some FF games that get beaten by other RPG's so to say it's almighty is just looking stupid,

you got a good point mate I like it

Personally..

While you've made some good points, I just wouldn't be too concerned with what other people think. Of course there's tons of good RPGs out there, some of which are Square related and some of which aren't.

I grew up on Final Fantasy games from the beginning. Why did I always choose FF games? Because the name symbolized quality, because I have yet to play a bad FF game that wasn't a spin-off; although I could care less for MQ and V, that's just personal taste though. But that didn't stop me from playing Dragon Quest, Illusions of Gaia, and any other kind of RPG. Even after playing many of those, in the end I still hold a few FF games very highly when compared to other RPGs. Not because I'm a fanboy, but because they were solid, good games and I enjoyed them thoroughly.

I have been aware of the "problem" that Final Fantasy gets more promotion than many other RPGs that may be outshined, and I have made effort to explore other RPGs over time. Unfortunately, when I've tried other RPGs, I've found it difficult to find a good one at times.. let alone worth investing 30+ hours into. So yeah, when a FF game comes out or even something by Square, I'll be willing to try it out because of their reputation, but that would never stop me from trying a different RPG out if it is worth my time.

Edit: It's kinda like any other genre if you think about it. Sure someone who enjoyed the Gran Turismo series will be excited to get the next game, even if there are tons of other racing games being released all the time, but I wouldn't blame them for sticking to what they enjoy. Or even something like Mortal Kombat, I've enjoyed MK games all my life and didn't invest the money/time to find out what SNK and all that was until I got older and could afford it. Of course if I had the opportunity to try something new I would have, but to invest my money in it? Not unless it got a killer review.

Totally agree with you. I

Totally agree with you. I love rpg games and have to search forever for a game that's not final fantasy when it comes to the consoles. Plus since they stopped doing the turn based combat I really hate the newer games.

Zenn would like to assure you that she is a girl. Not all gamers are boys, some are girls and some times they kick the boys arses. Unfortunately it seems to led to awkwardness...

Well put.

I love some RPGs that are dying out, and I've always blamed it on people not buying other tha FF/Square products.

Capcom, we NEED another BoF.

---
Sometimes, it's hard to be a Turn-Based man in a Real-Time world...

Actually, I'm more likely to

Actually, I'm more likely to get annoyed with this conversation:

Guy: Final Fantasy Seven is the best RPG ever!
Me: Really? I thought Final Fantasy Six* was better.
Guy: Um... I've never played that. Actually, I've only played Seven.

*or Final Fantasy IV, Chrono Trigger, Skies of Arcadia, etc.

FInal Fantasy sucks lately..........

FF 10 was to too linear with rarely any sidequests, X-2 was fruity and boring, 12 was boring with repetitive hunting, and I have less hope for 13 because it looks like 10 all over again.

Their latest installments aren't what they used to be over 10 years ago and I agree that Final Fantasy is not the best RPG, although it is the most popular.

And Rogue Galaxy sucks although it's created by those who made the great Dragon Quest 8.

I think Square doesn't care about the quality of their games anymore. They want to bring in more money by using their Final Fantasy name since it's their most popular franchise.

Right

I know also ppl who think that FF is kinda the only RPG Game, they are simply annoying. I have played many other RPGs, the best ones i have ever played were so far Final Fantasy VII and Secret of Mana.

That's awesome that you want

That's awesome that you want to raise awareness about other RPGs, but you're kinda preaching to the choir.
Hey, we all know that FF games are (usually) decent games, and we all know they get more attention than they (usually) deserve. I am sure most of us classic gamers would agree that FF has become bad, we all know!
IMO the last greats were FF6 and FF9.

So anyone who doesn't know about other great RPG series (like Dragon Quest, Suikoden, Elder Scrolls) is probably just uninformed.
You can help!
Go to your local gaming store and talk to the guys about how you want other RPGs represented on their shelves. They will care! You are their Customer!

You're not alone, many of us feel the same.

Rogue Galaxy is GOD!

I love Final Fantasy (1-6+9)and I've played them all (except 11). The main problem today is that the stories are getting quite retarded and all the character designs are crap. All the lead characters in the modern series are moody emo kids with the exception of Tidus who could still be a whiny bitch given the chance. I'm not saying 7 , 8, 10, and 11 are garbage, I just wouldn't put them on the same level as 1-6 and 9.
One thing I'd like to put out there is that some people, like me are Traditional RPG fans. So your Personas and Disgaeas and Eternal Sonatas won't be enjoyed as much by people my me. The other RPGS I play are:
-Dragon Quest (1, 2, 3, 4, 7, 8, and the Monsters Series)
-Chrono Trigger
-Robotrek
-Dark Cloud
-Dark Cloud 2
-Rogue Galaxy
-Chrono Cross
-Star Ocean(1 and 2)
-Legend of Dragoon
-Legend of Legaia
-Phantasy Star (1-4 and Online)
-Breathe of Fire (1 and 2)
-Pokemon Silver
-Actraiser
-Crystalis
-Snatcher (if it counts as an RPG)
annnnd.. I think that's about it.

The people who stick only

The people who stick only with the Final Fantasy series as their only RPG, and even go as far as to only include 7-13, to me are not really RPG fans. That's like saying your a big fighting game fan and only ever playing Mortal Kombat, or boasting to be the biggest FPS fanatic ever, yet you've only played Halo.

I started my RPG gaming back with the original Dragon Warrior (Dragon Quest) and went from there. Although you could considered the Treasure of Tarmin game on the good old Intellivision as being an RPG as well, and perhaps a sneek peek at the FPS genre to emerge many years later. I played small portions of Final Fantasy, missed the SNES ones, and eventually picked up again with 7. I was one of those people who actually looked things up before saying things like "Waa? Where is 4-6?!"

One of my favorite RPGs at the moment is the Wild Arms series, although I've only beat the first 3 of them, own the 4th and haven't picked up the 5th yet. And although the game stuck to no end and is probably considered on of the worst RPGs on the PSX, I enjoyed Beyond the Beyond.

So yeah, while I will buy and enjoy many of the games that Square releases, I'm not going to simply enjoy them just because it has their name on it.

I have to say I am quite

I have to say I am quite impressed that you mentioned Digital Devil Saga and the Shin Megami Tensei series. Not many people know of those games. Not anyones fault for that. The series doesn't get much publicity. i was even lucky to hear of it.

But yes, there are more RPGs out there besides Final Fantasy, which is a solid series no doubt. And there are other RPG developers besides Square out there. I admit that when I was a teen I overlooked many RPGs cause I was busy with the Final Fantasy series and other things made by Square. But in my own defence I was new to RPGs back then and didn't know what else is out there. Now I have a much broader view on the RPG universe. One that I hope many come to share with me.

I picked up Persona 3: FES just a few days ago. I would have had this game MUCH sooner but you think I could find it anywhere? It was a stroke of luck that I did actually.

Final Fantasy isn't the ONLY RPG but it still has its place

Out of the Box ate my first post . . .dang.

I agree, Final Fantasy is NOT the only RPG out there. It has its place though. I consider the Final Fantasy series like a gateway to bring people into the RPG world. It keeps you around with its many games and eventually you find yourself exploring the world and seeing what other residents you can meet.

And this is where people start experiencing Dragon Quest/Warrior, the Shin Megami Tensai games, other Squaresoft/Square Enix titles, Wild ARMS, and many, many more.

I also agree with one point touched upon that a lot of Final Fantasy fans seem to only include various groupings of the series. I mean, if you are indeed a true RPG fan than yes, you have tried or have an interest to try them all (I myself never had access to 1-3 and 5 until the remakes but I'm discovering and loving them). Overall in the end, a true RPG fan has sampled various games and not one or two appetizers.

The point also about attaching Final Fantasy to a title, sure it draws attention but as it is known that does not always bring about success. Might be off topic to mention this, but what about "The Spirits Within"? Sure, Final Fantasy was in the title buuut it still bombed.

In the end I agree that a lot of work is very much put into these massive worlds. To have it squandered because it does not have Chocobos or Moogles or Cid's popping up in the game, is wrong. And yes, try other RPG's too! I took a chance with Persona 3 FES (due to a recommendation by the gamestore clerk) and I do not regret it, heck both my boyfriend and I now love Shin Megami Tensai titles. For me, it is beginning to rival Final Fantasy in my heart. Not necessarily a bad thing.

Random question though, does anyone think that the fact, people who pretty much established the Final Fantasy series have anything to do with the successes of Blue Dragon and Lost Oddessy? Or do you feel they stand strong on their own gameplay and offerings?

You have a good point

The reason why some new RPG releases are hardly noticed is because they aren't really well known. Here's an example: Dark Cloud 2 (not sure if this is really an RPG or not, the box says so) is a squeal to one of the most popular games on the PS2, yet when it was released, nothing was shown in any game store. I think the same thing happened to Xenosaga as well. Only a small population of the gaming world know about these rare gems; like Disgaea. *Shameless plug time: BUY DISGAEA! ITS A GOOD GAME WITH LOTS OF TWISTS AND TURNS! Anyways your opinions actually make sense.

---------------------------------------------------------

Pissing people off is easy and fun. Don't deny it, you know its true

You heard it here first,

You heard it here first, Dakana aproves of the shameless plug! Disgaea is gooooooooood. SO good that you cant even buy it, but buy it anyway!!!

anyway away from that bit of plagirism (hehe), Xenosaga is a perfect way to show about how rpgs are messed around in the UK. We got Xenosaga part 2 ... and thats it. No part 1, or part 3.

How does that even work?

You NEVER got Xenosaga 1 or 3? But 2? Damn! That's almost like pulling a Final Fantasy of the past! Is it labelled 2 over there still or is it just called Xenosaga?

yup, its still called

yup, its still called Xenosaga episode 2. I suppose on the plus side we got an extra dvd with the cutscenes from the first game but its ... just not the same. Us brits get screwed around that way

I wonder why that is?

I mean, I wonder why you guys get screwed so bad? Are the laws stricter there with this kind of thing?

There is a good that come out of that.

There are some games that are released in the UK that never seen Western shores. For example: the UK got a PS2 version of "Altered Beasts", even though the game sucked, the west will never see it.

---------------------------------------------------------

Pissing people off is easy and fun. Don't deny it, you know its true

In the twilight of the

In the twilight of the Dreamcast's last year Big Ben published Shenmue 2 (in English) and Ubisoft released Evil Twin for the Dreamcast for the UK markets, but neither game was released in the US.

I imported both games and it puzzles me that they weren't released in North America when they even had NTSC compatibility. With a boot disc I was able to play both games without any problems at all.

When a game is finished and ready to be boxed, but the publisher says "Nay, we'll ignore this market" it baffles the mind.

-- --- .-. ... . / -.-. --- -.. .
I'm an old school gamer, but I'm still hip. Wait, when referring to oneself as, "Hip", does it reverse its meaning?